Although Force India has done well this year on the race tracks, there are still very serious worries about the team’s future funding because of difficulties that its two owners – Vijay Mallya and Roy Subrata Sahara – have run into.
Mallya’s deeply-indebted Kingfisher Airlines – which owes an estimated $1.4 billion – is now facing ever-deeper trouble. This morning a number of Kingfisher pilots in Mumbai decided to join the strike called by the company’s engineers, who are complaining that their salaries have not been paid in seven months. The Indian Directorate General of Civil Aviation says it is “examining the situation” and will decide whether it is safe for the airline to continue to operate flights. Almost all the shares in Kingfisher Airlines have been pledged to guarantee loans, many of them to other companies in the Mallya empire, but also to banks. Some of the debts have been sold on to other financial institutions. It has been clear for some time that Mallya has been running out people willing to loan him money. No-one appears to want to buy into the airline and thus there is strain on other companies in the empire. The local offshoot of the credit rating agency Moody’s has in recent days reduced the rating on the loans to Mallya’s United Spirits to junk status. This will increase the pressure on Mallya to sell the profitable liquor business to Diageo. The British firm is playing a canny game at the moment and says it wants control of the Indian business, or at least to be able to have a way to gain control in the future. Mallya is baulking at that but he seems to be running out of options. Even if he sells some of his stake in United Spirits, Mallya will not have enough money to pay Kingfisher’s debts, although it might allow him to find banks willing to keep the airline afloat.
In the meantime Sahara is also in significant trouble. At the end of August the Supreme Court of India ordered the company to pay a thumping $5 billion to the Securities and Exchange Board of India within three months, in order for the Sahara investor to be refunded. In addition the court ruled that investors should be paid 15 percent interest for each year. This means that the full extent of the repayment should be in the region of $10 billion. That money will be deposited in a nationalized bank that offers the maximum rate of interest and will then be repaid to investors. If this money is not paid the regulator has the right to seize and sell property and freeze all Sahara bank accounts. The firm was ordered to furnish the regulator with all the appropriate records by September 10, which it failed to do.
It is not clear where all this leaves the F1 team. It will need a solid budget to continue its activities and to fund its technology deals with Mercedes-Benz and with McLaren, not to mention the operational costs. There have been rumours for some time that the team is up for sale, but it seems that Mallya wants to remain involved so as to retain his image of being the leader of Indian motorsport. Whether the team can find someone who is willing to pay for that is another matter.











Shame. He’s done a good job, it appears, leading Force India. He’s a great ambassador for the sport. Airlines are dumb businesses to be involved with. The industry globally has a chequered past. Perhaps he should have stuck to selling beer. Much more money in that.
When one of India’s e-papers, First Post Business, writes an article titled “Is Vijay Mallya India’s worst businessman?”, it brings into some doubt how good he is at anything. As of today (2nd October) Kingfisher Airlines seems to have been grounded by the authorities – it has debts of just short of £1billion so seems unlikely to fly again any time soon – and a grounded airline is rarely saleable. With Mallya being responsible for much of this debt, he is raising cash everywhere – now, reportedly, loans against Kingfisher Towers, his ancestral property. £70million has been suggested from that. Since most of Force India’s headline sponsors are Mallya companies, if he loses control of them – or they no longer exist – he won’t simply be able to dip into their marketing budgets any longer….
Tata seem to be doing a brilliant job with Jaguar, maybe they’d like to buy it and call the team Jaguar Racing
Ouch. The pain of that humiliating time period still stings. Still amazes me how Ford’s great F1 history built up from 1967 could be squandered in such a short time.
Interesting read, but really nothing new to report. Any of us who follow these things are only too aware of this, as are many in and around F1 that Force India is/could be up for sale. The asking price whispered from what has been rumored, is of such a large degree that would on the surface preclude any prospective buyers beating a hasty path to Mallya’s door I would imagine.
If one buys something for $1 and owns if for a number of years, with no significant added value structural improvements to any buildings, equipments, etc being part of the initial purchase, it then falls to market forces to decide the current value of your $1 purchase, and thus a ballpark sale asking price, does it not? Based on this concept, it would seem that a somewhat overestimated value is being sought, one which I would have thought will not attract a single buyer.
Whilst I applaud the efforts of the Team, the owner seems to becoming the Nero of his Indian business empire……………..fiddling without paying attention to the inferno at his door.
>Although Force India has done well this year on the race tracks
Er, about that:
WCC position last year: 6th
WCC target for this year: 5th
WCC current standing: 7th
I know, they’ve got more points than this time last year. Like most of the rest of the (much tighter) field.
Don’t they have bankruptcy reorganization over there? Airlines go under all the time over here and have their debts slashed in court procedures, make their employees take big cuts in pay while never missing a flight.
Perhaps this is a return to the days of gentlemen race drivers ? Unpaid and just enjoying the racing! Ex Air Canada aircraft mechanic victim here!
Any truth to the story that neither di Resta nor Hulkenberg have been paid for some months either?
That would be on keeping with his ways of doing business.
Indeed.
The word was that neither has seen any money for this season as yet. They may never see any!
A shame that with the Mclaren and Mercedes seats filled, there’s nowhere to go for Di Resta and Hulk…
So if he’s not been paying wages / bills, have they been paying Merc and Mclaren? Other suppliers? Sounds like they could struggle to put a car on the grid next year…
Given that Nico will finally get the acid test next year, there might be a Mercedes seat in 2013.
Just reminds me of Flavio. Has no interest in F1, just wants to swan around Monaco in his yacht, dripping in ‘gold’.
Not too sure on how it works but would Prodrive or Lola not be interested in the team? Mclaren tie up already in place, UK facilities and two awesome drivers? Happy day’s no?
I was out for a lunchtime jog today and observed the helicopter taking off from Prodrive. It got me thinking about Mr Richards ambitions for F1 entry a few years back (and his previous involvements of course).
Strikes me he seems to have a very successful business at the moment – and as they say F1 is a great way to make a small fortune…..if you start with a big one
Not a few big names in motorsport have balked at F1 – DAMS, DOME, Prodrive. TWR, Pacific and Lola might wish they had, in hindsight.
Unfortunately Lola Cars is currently in administration. Future being uncertain, the firm is now struggling to supply spares for existing clients, let alone even thinking about any new projects.
Prodrive seems healthy, but I can’t see a specialist like that being able to raise enough sponsorship funds to race in F1 at any level, unless they run a team specifically for some major backer (like a car manufacturer, or someone like Red Bull).
Funnily enough, they also say that the way to make a small fortune in the airline business is to start with a large fortune.
I wonder how long it will be until the pro-Mallya fanboys troll the page with how Joe is biased against Vijay? LOL!
A very well written article and a pleasure to read, so thanks very much for this, Joe.
If this link is ok with Joe: This is the latest news from the main UK aerospace magazine ‘Flight’
http://www.flightglobal.com/news/articles/kingfisher-suspends-flights-after-declaring-partial-lockout-377175/
Hang about – the team’s for sale?!? I seem to remember Joe insisting that Mallya had sold up about 12 months ago!
Did I say Mallya was selling? I said the team was for sale. Who knows who really owns it. Do you?
Can’t remember who wrote the piece (may even have been you Joe) but I remember reading a column a few years back referring to an un-named team I think from the 1990s. When asked who actually owned it, the team principal replied “I’m not altogether sure…”
3 of the 9 directors of Force India Formula One Limited are now Sahara linked, not Force India people (including Subrata Roy Sahara), and have been for 11 months now.
It’s pretty clear they did sell a big chunk of the company to Sahara, the question is how much did they sell? There’s been various definitive statements of it being 42.5%, but I can’t find a formal document to confirm that.
Force India Formula One Limited has a parent company “Orange India Holdings Sarl” anyway, so perhaps the next question is who owns that now?
As far as I understand the Sahara *buy in* to Force India for supposedly $120 mil……………..could probably be reworded as…..*acquiring some assets after renaging on loans* from Sahara. Did any real money change hands in this deal? We will probably never know the answer to that question.
You’d have thought going after his yatch made more sense………..:) but hey, maybe they already own that!
Good news, Danny Behar is to buy the Mallya empire for $1. He wishes to move on to bigger things.
That can’t be true. Danny Boy would never spend a dollar of his own money…
Its a shame about vijay with money troubles he is a good embassador for india but i feel more for paul and nico more regards to their future and wages….
Perhaps Joe can lift his “spirits” a little by buying him one bourbon, one scotch (Whyte & Mackay of course) and one beer (Kingfisher).
Oh dear, quite a pickle..
Joe – what implication does a possible FI bankruptcy have for Mr E? Does he still have the requirement to deliver a certain number of cars to each of the circuits as part of his role as the sport’s promoter?
Salaries not paid in seven months? Really? That’s no small matter and I’d complain about that too…
I believe all flying has been suspended today.
Today it was announced that Kingfisher had locked out all staff following a labor action by some of its personnel, which allegedly caused intimidation of others. All flights were cancelled for the day. It doesn’t take a genius to see where this is headed.
Reminds me of the advice I received about doing business in that part of the world. Make sure you split the budget into three halves. The half to start, the half progress payment in the middle, and the half they’ll stiff you for at the end.
As an F1 fan, I get awfully tired of so-called pundits slagging away with half-baked and often ill-informed opinions. Come on Joe, it’s no secret you’re involved with another team and your continual slamming of Force India is not without an agenda. If we just stand back for a moment and look at Sahara/Force India’s involvement in F1, we can’t help but applaud Vijay’s contributions over the past five years. He not only provides hundreds of jobs in the UK, he has also given a number of drivers an opportunity they probably wouldn’t enjoy. Think of how Nico Hulkenberg was ruthlessly dropped by Williams; not to mention how many teams overlooked Paul Di Resta. Whatever Vijay’s corporate challenges, let’s try to be fair. Competing with teams with a hell of a lot more experience and much deeper pockets, Vijay et al is running with the leaders. Look at the record. Vijay is no dilettante, he’s a racer, through and through. His passion for the sport is demonstrated at every level. How is the sport going to grow if we continually denigrate unreasonably every new team and it’s owners?
I have explained how things are several times. There is a difference between a car company and a racing team and I respect that division. If you don’t trust me, then you can get lost. I really don’t care. I have been completely up front about things and if you don’t respect me enough to believe that – and if you do not have sufficient knowledge of my views and writings in this respect – then you are in the wrong place. Go away and whine somewhere else! The Force India story is entirely valid. Jobs in F1 and beyond depend on these people.
Disenchanted, ignoring your jab regarding Joe’s involvement with Caterham (cars), I think you’ve missed the point of this story. You’ve also completely missed the very first words – “Although Force India has done well this year on the race tracks.”
If Mallya and Sahara’s companies go down, Force India will go down with them unless someone else buys the team.
I don’t believe the issue about the F1 team is going to be effected by the Sahara companies situation. It is the Mallya empire which is floundering in debt and sinking.
Besides, as I have already mentioned prior, the whispered asking price for the team which I have heard, is bloated in the extreme, and thus making it probably unsellable anyway.
Who paid for this year’s racing?
Who paid for this year’s racing?
Well if you look at the main sponsors on the cars, they are basically companies owned by the Mallya consortium.
If you believe the Sahara involvement was not really a buy into the team and thus no funding provided…………….you can probably say other than any FOM monies, the team is being supported from the marketing budgets of the various Mallya companies and the free/cheap engine supply from Mercedes. Other than this, who else is paying?……………..perhaps the creditors are subsidizing it all………..
Seemingly despite the Mallya companies not being awash with cash, it appears to have no effect on his personal spendings and lifestyle, does it?
Not the right answer. I think that Sahara paid for the whole thing.
Really?
Is this what you know…..or what you think Joe?
Seven months without pay! Wow!
Also wanted to add, whatever Joe’s association with any other team in F1 may be, I have always read his words as being professional and unbiased reporting on the world of F1.
Keep it up pal and don’t tolerate some of the fools that abound………:)
Unitedspirits website is now down:
http://www.unitedspirits.in/
Down for maintainence I would imagine. It’s working now.