Green Notebook from Sotteville-lès-Rouen

I am sure this cannot be true but the word “sotte” in French means stupid and so a place called Sotteville-lès-Rouen is presumably a place where stupid people live – or have lived in the past. Place names tend to be very old, except for airports which are usually named after politicians, presumably because they are loud, irritating and cause disruption in life. I suppose one day soon we will be able to fly in and out of Trumpton International Airport…

Anyway, the suburb of Rouen I am discussing is nowhere near Renault headquarters in Boulogne-Billancourt, but if one threw a Renault executive into the river at global headquarters, the body would eventually float past Sotteville.

Still, the company is big in these parts… There’s a walloping great factory just down the road in Cleon and a secret test track at CTA (secrets are always better with acronyms). This actually stands for Centre Technique Aubevoye which, to quote a company website, is “a secret Renault Group base” which is “hidden in Normandy’s forests and skirting the meandering Seine”.

This is “classified as confidential” which obviously explains why there is  web page about it…

What is it about the French and secrets? When he was FIA President, Jean Todt once put out a press release announcing “a secret settlement” with Ferrari. This was a painful and expensive punishment for Ferrari, which had been caught… (um, what’s another word?). Ah yes, “pushing into the grey areas” of the rules. It was a secret because the sport would have been embarrassed if its most famous team had been revealed, so the crime and the punishment were both classified, although Todt wanted the world to know that something had been done. I still laugh about the “secret settlement” whenever I think of it. Jean had a sense of humour…

Anyway, the company boss Louis Renault used to live not far from Sotteville, in a place called Herqueville, where he built a magnificent estate, before the company was taken off his hands by the French government, which argued that he let the nasty invading Germans use his factories. He himself said that “it is better to give them the butter, or they’ll take the cows” but then, according to his family, he was murdered by the government so that he’d be out of the way…

Where is this leading? Well, the point I am making is that Renault has secrets and one day I am sure we will find out why someone thought it was a good idea to rehire Flavio Briatore, the man who did Renault almost as much harm as Carlos Ghosn (the former Renault boss who had to escape from Japan in a packing case).

Personally, I think they should move Renault headquarters to Sotteville…

Just to finish off, Sotteville’s only real claim to fame is that it was the site (or rather the target) of the first combat raid of the US Eighth Air Force and thus the first place in Europe to be pummelled by B17s. They were after the extensive rail yards located there…

I am sure you are now asking what this has to do with the Spanish Grand Prix in Barcelona. This is a fair question. Any normal person going from Barcelona to the Red Bull Ring in Austria, does not go by way of Sotteville. The normal route is along the coast to the Cote d’Azur, then across Italy to Venice and over the Alps to Villach in Austria. This is just short of 1,000 miles, but  I didn’t do any of that. Instead I drove 700 miles home to Normandy and then 800 to get to the Red Bull Ring, so around 1,500, which is about 500 miles more than logical. I did get to hang out briefly with my nearest and dearest during the triple-header, but that was not the real explanation. The truth is that since the British deserted their European citizens and deprived us of the right to vote (which has since been returned once Brexit was over), many people like me are disillusioned with their country and so I am in the process of becoming a French national, or at least dual nationality, which makes life easier.

Part of this process requires applicants to do a French exam, to see if they can speak and write French to a sensible degree. I think this is a good idea but in my region they have only a handful of such exams each year and the only one I could make (thanks to the F1 calendar) was the Tuesday after Spain. So the reason I have been quiet in the last few days is that I have been driving and taking exams…

The Green Notebook from Montmelo is largely filled with scrawls about drivers, aside from some notes of astonishment regarding a Mr Briatore’s new job and the fact that the two parties do not even agree about what his role will be. Briatore sent out a message saying he will be “executive director” of Alpine F1, but the official announcement refers to him as “executive advisor”. My conclusion is that he is there to sell Alpine (the whole car division) within a couple of years, after he has tried to increase its value. Hopefully, he won’t be telling drivers to crash this time.

I am not sure I’d want to work there, but apparently Renault boss Luca de Meo thinks Briatore will be a magnet for talent. Honestly, if I was an Alpine employee I’d be sending out my CV to Aston Martin, Williams or Visa Cash App, all of which are in the F1 cluster and all of which are hiring. I write this in the knowledge that dozens of CVs are arriving each week at the aforementioned places, so Briatore’s first task is to stop the rot.

Good luck with that…

Officially there are still nine of the 20 Formula 1 seats available for 2025 – but the reality is that the silly season is effectively over with only one seat really still up for grabs. The Visa Cash App RB Team recently took up its option on Yuki Tsunoda for 2025, after he got an offer from Audi. This means that the team will now choose between Daniel Ricciardo and Liam Lawson. In recent days, the ever-indiscreet Helmut Marko has said that the choice will be Lawson and the logical thing to do now is to try to give him as much seat time in the car as possible, so if you’re a Danny Ric fan think twice about buying tickets to races after the summer break…

We know that Red Bull, Ferrari and McLaren are all settled and, although there is yet to be an announcement, it is clear that Mercedes has decided that it will replace Lewis Hamilton with 17-year-old youngster Andrea Kimi Antonelli. He turns 18 in August but Mercedes is not pushing it and he will start racing for Merc next year. There were discussions about putting him into the second Williams for the rest of this year but that might be a bit much and he is thus focussing on trying to have more success in Formula 2.  He has been more than a match for his Prema Racing team-mate Oliver Bearman, who is going to Haas in 2025 so that Ferrari will have  youngster in training for the post-Hamilton (or post Leclerc era). The problem is that this year neither has done that well. Formula 2 introduced a new car and no-one seems to have mastered it yet. The championship is scrappy, with no dominant driver and eight of the 11 teams having won either reverse-grid Sprint races (which are basically irrelevant) or the more important Feature races, but that does not include Prema nor Hitech. The latter runs championship leader Paul Aron, but he is yet to win a race and owes his lead in the title race to six podium finishes in the 12 races.

If the Mercedes drive was still available we would not be writing about Carlos Sainz considering the choice between Williams and Sauber-Audi, and Alpine (if one believes the post-Briatore rumours). Both teams think that they have a good chance of signing Carlos and both are willing to pay the same kind of money, so it really is  choice of which team Carlos thinks will best for him in the next couple of years.  Williams might not be looking very good right now, but things are on the move. They have more CVs arriving than do Sauber. The secret to modern F1 (which Renault has yet to understand) is that everything takes longer to achieve than you think.

The market is dependent on Sainz’s decision, which should come this week. It was meant to be last week but it did not happen. We will see where he ends up, but logic says Williams is his best choice for 2025 and 2026. But logic and F1 are not always best buddies.

Aston Martin has yet to confirm Lance Stroll in its second car, but no-one has any doubt that the owner’s son will still be in a car alongside Fernando Alonso next year. He will probably have a two-year deal to get him to the end of 2026.

The most reliable sources say that Alpine has already taken up an option it had on Pierre Gasly and Jack Doohan, the team’s reserve driver, is clearly being lined up for the second seat. The team’s biggest problem is not the drivers.

Esteban Ocon decided a while ago that he would depart (one wonders if he knew about Briatore’s arrival before or after the decision was made) but he was on the shopping list of various teams. He is going to end up with Bearman at Haas.

So this means that the one seat open in 2025 is the second Audi, unless they have convinced Sainz to go there. It seems like both Audi and Williams have Valtteri Bottas as their Plan B. If Danny Ric is on the market, will it make a difference? No-one is showing much interest in Kevin Magnussen and while one can make good arguments for Guanyu Zhou or Aston Martin reserve driver Felipe Drugovich as being much-needed representatives of big markets, I doubt anyone will be swayed by that, unless (a lot of) money is involved. Most teams are now financially sound and the logic of pay-drivers is weak as scoring points brings more dosh than simply being given it by someone’s daddy or their sponsor.

The one other thing to watch for is the mid-season market because once the 2025 deals are sorted out, some of the teams might want to get rid of a current driver…

Right, I must stop now. I need to sleep and drive (but not at the same time)…

65 thoughts on “Green Notebook from Sotteville-lès-Rouen

  1. Merci, Joe, et bonne chance avec votre examens. Any chance that Briatore will bring back Nelson Piquet Jr. !? (joking)

  2. As a Norman myself, I take a little umbrage at your translation of Sotteville as “stupid city”. The word “Sotte” is derived from the old norse “Sotì” from which comes the english “Soot”. “Ville” meaning a big house or a farm, Sotteville was most likely a place where someone was selling charcoal during Norman times.

    That said, whether or not Renault people just covered themselves with soot in hiring Briatore remains an open question…

    Always a treat to read your amazing blog.

  3. I would have thought the considerable experience and skill of Valtteri would see him in the Sauber seat. They need the help. C’est la vie.

      1. He’s a top lad but Doohan’s not an ace in the making. His dad had worked very hard supporting him though to be fair.

        I’ve said it many times but Victor Martins is a serious talent’ certainly the pick if the Alpine juniors and ought to be a shoe-in to be Gasly’s teammate.

        Shame it is being wasted in the F2 lottery this year.

  4. Apropos the naming of airports: a few years ago some Canadian japesters started a petition to oblige former PM Stephen Harper to change his name to Calgary International Airport. This, alas, failed.

  5. Personally I don’t see the logic of selling the Alpine brand. They’re designing and building multiple new cars, plus have made Esprit Alpine trim to posh up regular Renaults. The F1 team is more likely.

      1. That all depends on where you are. In my area of Washington state, not in a metro center or large town they are every where.

        On a fifteen minute drive today I counted 32 EVs from eleven different manufacturers (Porsche, Tesla, Nissan, Mercedes, Chevrolet, Rivian, Polestar, Kia, Jaguar, Audi, Ford). If more affordable ones were available I’m sure the number would be even higher. You can get a Tesla model 3 for around $35k various government discounts in this state, and a friend just got a used 7 year old Nissan Leaf for $8k that drives as new with 85% left on the battery. While in no way indicative of the worldwide market, there are many enclaves with similar numbers.

      2. More people than I know who bought a petrol car I’ve just realised. The highest volume selling car last year was an EV, the Model 3, so I think it’s fair to say they’ve shifted a few.

    1. There is a lot of logic selling the Alpine brand…it has failed to become any more relevant than it was when the team was called Renault F1. As a bit of a Renault fan myself, I’d argue that the RS branding on their road vehicles had more appeal and tradition in comparisons with the Alpine variants.

      My question has always been, why would you spend good money on advertising a brand that will be going full electric in the near term is series that isn’t electric?

      Perhaps the money folk at Renault, upstream of Sottesville, will argue that the ROI on the Alpine brand exposure is in the order of multiple magnitudes, but in reality, how many people a) know what an alpine is and b) would buy one?

      I’ve always felt that this is a bit like if Porsche decided to wrap their Hypercars with Ruf decals….it just doesnt make sense.

    1. Yes he is.

      His F1 drives last year were more of an indicator than his F2 results.

      F2 is good entertainment but it has become crystal clear that real talent can get mired if a team can’t get their cars or tyres to work.

  6. I compiled a list of your 2025 drivers for my own reference. This is what I’m understanding you to be saying…. Mind you, I haven’t had coffee yet today so I could be misunderstanding.

    Merc – Russell & Antonelli

    Ferrari – Lewis & Chuck

    Red Bull – Max & Checo

    McLaren – Lando & Oscar

    Williams – Alex & (Sainz or Bottas)

    Aston – Fernando & Lance

    RB – Yuki & Liam

    Alpine – Gasly & Doohan

    Haas – Bearman & Ocon

    Sauber (Audi) – Hulk & (Sainz or Bottas)

    Out – Danny Ric, Kev, Logan, Zhou,

  7. Joe would Antonelli’s deal only be a one year deal as if he’s on probation/trial with the team so Merc can keep there options open for 2026 in case Max suddenly comes on the market? If Merc signs Max for 2026 who do you think would get the nod for that second seat next to to him ?

      1. I hope Max will not waste a complete season of his career racing at the back end of the top ten with a Red Bull Powertrain Ford engine. Verstappen will need Mercedes power to take on McLaren and Ferrari in 2026 and beyond.

    1. Stephen… I seem to recall you suggesting Russell is the one on borrowed time at Merc if Max enters thr frame, not Antonelli?

  8. Great read as always.

    The last part is intriguing.

    Presumably, to have the new bod, step in, he needs to be free of obligations elsewhere?

    That makes me think of K mag / Bearman, Ocon / Doohan or Ric / Lawson.

    Does Sergeant get a repreive?

  9. I spent a year living in Sotteville-lès-Rouen in university. The kindest thing I can say about it is that it is a short tram ride from the centre-ville…

  10. The whole Alpine saga makes soap operas look tame! It seems hypocritical that people calling for more transparency around the Horner affair are welcoming Briatore with open arms. F1 and moral consistency clearly don’t go together.
    I’ve just read that Gasly has signed a long term deal to stay at Alpine. He probably didn’t have any realistic other choice but I wonder how confident he really is in the team’s long term future? It would seem silly for Sainz to go there but then who knows what Flav has whispered in his ear? It’s very sad that a driver of his calibre is reduced to looking at drives for back marker teams (regardless of future investment, that’s where they are currently). I hope he manages to pick the best option for 2026 and beyond. The whole excitement and positive vibes around the original Audi announcement seem to be long gone now and most people seem to think they’re going to struggle and perhaps not have enough investment and stability.

    I hope you pass your exam and get your citizenship sorted. Although France isn’t looking that much better than here in Britain with regard to the politics and elections at the moment.

  11. Joe,

    In Trumptonville is Miss (Linda???) Lovelace the lead character in the Trumpton Mayors hush money conviction? Who is the deep throat that breaks that story? 😉

    I cannot help but think that the Austrian GP is heading to another disaster. Gravel strips along the edge of many corners, direct to the asphalt, no kerb in between. So if you do run wide, at some point someone will, then they screw up the racing line for everyone that follows, with pebbles littered everywhere! Do we have to wait for someone to spin on the dispersed gravel and collect someone else to realize that was a dumb idea? Do we go to safety car for a clean up in the race? Because it is so dumb the FIA elected to call it the “perfect” solution! I predict a comment in the notebook that will say “Perfect” corners, not so perfect and it will be back to the drawing board, again!

    1. there’s a 2 metre wide kerb in between asphalt and gravel.

      these guys can race their cars at 10 cm from barriers in Monaco, Montreal and also at some stupid desertic location. Why should they have problems at staying away from gravel in Zeltweg ?

      on the other hand you are right, as LM wants to improve the show, a few pebbles will give the opportunity to call the SC if the race is a bit boring

  12. “Trumpton International Airport”: Did you know that a bill to rename Dulles (larger airport serving Washington DC) to DJT International was introduced in the US House back in April? Not likely to pass, but in the current American climate one cannot be certain.

  13. Any chance that Sainz ends up waiting himself out of a drive for next year?

    Also, is anyone in F2 performing their way in to some testing etc., or do teams already have their opinions set on everyone there?

  14. I must say that Flav lurching back into the paddock was an unpleasant shock — although perhaps it shouldn’t have been a surprise, given Enstone’s current omnishambular condition.

    Actually, now that Flav is in place, they have the opportunity to really put together an F1 management Dream Team. Bring Dany Bahar in on the commercial side, Maurizio Arrivabene taking care of HR (pour encourager les autres), Gino Rosato as Global Director Of Standing Around At The Back Of The Garage, and design can be handled by one of Nick Wirth’s old CFD machines. Fantastic.

  15. As you’re far from being a newcomer to France, I assume you’re confident about your exam performance… but what language gets spoken (the most) when you’re at home?

    Does French citizenship have other requirements that some of us might find surprising?

  16. ”Call me Ishmael.” Looks like your own “white whale”, is back to haunt the back channels of your mind. If only we could understand a word of his stumbling attempts, at speaking in English.

  17. daddy stroll won’t give up on Lance until 2026. His only chance of a championship is having a car at least a second faster than anything else, probably more like two, and that generally only happens in the first year of new radical regs. Of course he also needs to be paired with a subservient second driver; either from the start or replacing the incumbent after a race or two and it’s clear the car is that far ahead.

  18. I hope you don’t lose your personal sense of humor translated into French after you got “la nouvelle nationalité”. Fingers crossed!

  19. Hi Joe, when Dorrilton first bought Williams I had the impression you were quite sceptical about them because of the secrecy of who they really were. Since then they appear to have shown themselves to be pretty serious about getting Williams up the grid – does it look good from what you see of the team in the paddock?

  20. Shorter than usual, but always ticking the more relevant boxes in your unique way of writing.

    Have a nice and safe drive, et succés aux examens!

  21. THANK YOU JOE! Great article as always, looking forward to it every week .. Sometimes its better to read your blog than watch a race – you really helped to keep me a fan and stay in touch with F1 during some of the last years…

    (glad I held on AS the current season is a magnificent one)

    Looking forward to the virtual audience on Monday!

    Hopefully then, you won’t have to go to sleep when a most interesting topic arises haha, as your concluding sentceces today ars one hell of a cliff hanger…

  22. Thank you Joe and good luck in Austria. I’m just crossing the channel, the midnight ferry full of schoolkids of all the EU countries it seems. I did the UK citizenship for similar reasons. A cultural test too, and they hesitantly accepted my Hungarian MA in English as proof of my language skills instead of doing the test. Set me back 1400 pounds. They are open about needing the money for border control. The FR test sounds like just the one step? Perhaps cheaper too? Bon courage

  23. Hi Joe, as interesting as always.
    If VER stays at RBR for 2025 (as seems likely right now) do you think there’s any real chance of him moving before 2027?
    To me the VER situation seems to depend on two issues –
    1. Which team does he think will have the best overall package come 2026?
    2. Will there be a seat for him if he waits until 2027?
    Of course he could – depending on who *does* end up best overall – find himself on the positive side of a ‘seat buy-out’ as per the Ferrari-RAI-ALO situation in 2010 if they felt that he could get more out the car than their current drivers (whoever they may be). But is that really likely for a team who has the best car?
    Any thoughts?

    1. Max will do what is best for Max. I think he’ll stay until at least the end of 2026, at which point we will all know the engine situation.

  24. I haven’t enjoyed a piece of journalism as much as your second paragraph for a long time Joe!
    Please keep reminding the world what journalists should actually do.

  25. Trumpton: We Brits of a certain age remember a TV programme of the same name set in a village that looked not dissimilar to Camberwick Green.

  26. What’s your take on the continued accusations towards Christian Horner by Jos Verstappen? Is there truly an internal power struggle and/or underhandedness or is this just an example of extreme posturing by the senior Verstappen in attempt to steer Max elsewhere?

    From an outsider perspective, it seems juvenile, unprofessional and outright belligerent to see the father of one of the greatest drivers of recent histroy repeatedly interject himself into the conversation. It is even more surprising that given the level of poise and focus that Max carries himself. One Verstappen seems to thrive on drama, the other seems to gracefully brush it off.

  27. G’day Joe, I recently went through the difficult process of getting French nationality. I empathise. Apart from the language test, I also had a meeting with the local gendarmes to check that my verbal answers corresponded with the written ones from a few months ago, I deduced, as well as questions about my integration into French society; to see if I did that rather than hung out exclusively with other Aussies, for example. And later, at the immigration office, an examination on French history ( I forgot the date of the Revolution! ) and French laws ( How many wives can you have? ) and politics. Getting all the documents together and translated was a job and a half. But good now. I’m a Frog too! And very happy so.

    Most races are very exciting now as the teams are so close to each other, even the slowies. I love it.

    As for F1 TV, the, I assume, response of canal+ to the loss of clients is to limit the value of the OTT service. Short term gain, perhaps, for long term loss, certain. If I’m right, it’s petty. In the meantime, I can no longer watch a delayed telecast of quali or race. Big bummer for me.

Leave a comment