Notebook from DXB

It’s prayer time and the muezzin is singing his adhan out there somewhere in the darkness. The shoe shine boys are busy, but the lounge is still quiet. It’s 04-something and although they have started serving breakfast, the body clock says it’s time for a glass of wine, and so the two thoughts are combined. It’s Sauvignon Blanc and scrambled eggs, and it’s not outrageous. We’ve been living on dubious 7-Eleven egg sandwiches for the last few days, with some of Japan’s wonderful chocolate, known as Crunky, which comes in useful shiny sheep-dropping sized balls, which do not melt. They are probably rice-based but I’ve never investigated. Crunky is Crunky.

There are six of us in this quiet corner of the lounge. Some of us here left Shiroko this morning, heading north to Nagoya, then took the Shinkansen super expresses (otherwise known as Bullet Trains) up to Tokyo and flew out of Narita. Others stood on the opposite platform at Shiroko and went south, on the Kintetsu Line to Osaka Namba and from there to Renzo Piano’s Kansai International Airport. And now here we all are, back together in Dubai International Airport (known as DXB), changing planes and all bound for different destinations. Next week we will all meet up again in Austin, Texas.

The flight attendant on the plane in Osaka Kansai asked me how it was that I knew so many of the other passengers. It’s Formula 1, I said, we go to the same places. We use the same planes. This was Monday night, and the planes were filled with those who work Sunday nights and cannot just run off to the nearest airport as soon as the chequered flag has fallen. I’ve always wanted to write an article to show where F1 people are 12 hours after a race. Quite often, we are still in the media centres, long after the drivers and team bosses are home. We all do different things and meet in different time zones and different places. I rarely go through Dubai without meeting someone I know.

The Japanese green notebook pages begin with two notes: “This is a pen test,” it says. “This pen works fine”. There is also a note about avoiding green KitKat because it is flavoured with tea, rather than something interesting like wasabi, the wonderful Japanese horseradish that can blow the back of your head clean off, if you eat too much of it.

There is another note that says “Halloween”. The Japanese, being heavily into things spiritual, enjoy Halloween much more than some other nations, and the build-up to the Eve of All Hallows (which is October 31) begins earlier. The symbols are the same, with orange pumpkins and witchy women with pointy hats and broomsticks. On Saturday in Suzuka, a pumpkin the size of a pillbox (military rather than medical), appeared in front of the gate between the circuit and the Circuit Hotel. The rooms in this establishment are allotted to the F1 teams and most of the media stay in hotels in Shiroko and ride the five kilometres to the track on buses provided for them, at set hours of the day (and night).

The Japanese have been in F1 longer than all the other Asians and they “get it” much more than the others. The fans are enthusiastic, polite and they know a lot. They want to see a successful Japanese F1 driver, and they want Honda to do well, but any driver can earn mythical status if he (or she, come to that) can capture the imagination of the fans. It is hard to explain the passion that exists in Japan for Ayrton Senna, one just has to accept it. The Japanese of today love heroes, be they characters from manga or anime, or the knights of medieval Japan, but in among them is Senna. No other F1 driver has ever enjoyed the same status. It is a little odd, but we can always hope that we will one day find another like him.

F1 and Asia remains a love affair that always seems just about to happen, but something holds back the two parties. We have visited many Asian countries, but the results have been very different from one place to the next. It’s rather odd, trying to figure out why one works and another does not.

It looks like the next adventure for F1 in Asia is going to be a race in Hanoi, the capital city of Vietnam, in order to help the country on its mission to develop a stronger tourist industry. The word in that the Vietnamese government, under President Tran Dai Quang is willing to invest whatever it takes in a race to try to change the image of the country and develop new revenues from international visitors. What does Hanoi mean to the average Westerner? The Vietnam War? Jane Fonda? The infamous Hoa Lo Prison, known as The Hanoi Hilton? It is all pretty negative. And yet, Hanoi, so they say, is a great place with a lot of advantages that spring from its days under French colonial rule. In 1903, for example, the city suffered an outbreak of bubonic plague (never a good idea) and the French decided that the whole place needed to be cleaned up and fixed. So they built new drainage systems and wide avenues were cut through the town to make it a little healthier. Colonial architecture is still widespread, although the city was heavily bombed by the US in the early 1970s.

Since the late 1980s the Vietnamese authorities have tried to liberalise the country’s economy and to reform and modernize its government. The country wants to be more competitive. There is still tight control over political expression and problems with inefficiency and corruption, but what drives Vietnam is money and so they want more tourists to drive business. The country currently has around four million international tourists a year, although many of these are backpackers, and Vietnam wants to pull in the high-spending tourists who tend to be people who attend Grands Prix. It is probably worth noting that south east Asia, and specifically Vietnam, are key target markets for F1’s partner Heineken.

Drinks companies are still big sponsors in F1, but they have learned from tobacco and have been very careful not to upset regulators. This is why there has been so much discussion about who will drive the second Williams in 2018. This is now the best drive up for grabs, although McLaren has not yet confirmed Fernando Alonso. This will probably happen next week, in the run-up to Austin. The Williams decision may take longer, but the team is planning to run a test with Paul di Resta and Robert Kubica, although Felipe Massa remains a candidate unless Williams can extract a very good deal from Mercedes to take on Pascal Wehrlein who, to be fair, seems to be the best youngster on the market at the moment. The problem is that Wehrlein is too young. Martini, the team’s primary sponsor, is bound by a voluntary agreement amongst alcohol companies not to use models or ambassadors under 25 to sell their drink. The team already has Lance Stroll and so with Wehrlein it would mean two youngsters and the team might have to employ a third to do the promotional work, in much the same way that Mika Hakkinen has done over the years with Johnnie Walker. The Williams cars in Japan ran in full Martini livery, but those who watch for these things will see that Stroll was unbranded when he was not in the car.

However, the advantages of having Wehrlein are important. He is quick and what the team needs more than anything is a youngster to inspire and motivate the staff, he would come with financial support from Mercedes (probably in the form of a reduced engine bill) or perhaps with the factory engine and transmission being used, rather than Williams doing its own. We will have to see how it all turns out in the end, but clearly Williams needs to do better in the future. It is not alone in this respect, because the level of competition in F1 is very high at the moment. It is not as easy as once it was and even big name teams have to fight hard for good results. At the moment we have Williams, McLaren and Renault, all of which should be doing better. Others have been trying to argue that Red Bull is going to run into trouble as Renault develops with no contract in place between the two parties for 2019 and 2020. On the face of it, this means that Red Bull could be in trouble and might have to use Honda engines, but the truth is that, in the finest tradition of F1, the devil of understanding the game is in the detail. It is possible for Renault and Red Bull not to have a contract and yet for Renault to have to supply the team… How, you might ask; well, if Renault had committed to supply Red Bull in a deal it signed in 2015 with the Formula One group, which runs until the end of 2020, then the apparently contradictory situation could be explained, couldn’t it? Renault agreed to the terms on offer because it wanted to get a commercial deal in place that would allow it to borrow against future contracted revenues in order to put together a team, without having to get the shareholders to pay. It is all very clever stuff and it means that Red Bull can actually choose between Renault and Honda engines in 2019 and 2020. There is a fairly widespread feeling in F1 that Red Bull is winding down its F1 involvement after 2020, but in recent says there has been one discordant note in this theory: Red Bull just signed up a quartet of young kart racers for the future, including Jack Doohan, the son of motorcycle legend Mick, plus three others. There is no doubt that Red Bull would love to have Aston Martin engines in the future, but that does not mean that the drinks firm will leave. It might sell Scuderia Toro Rosso at some point, but then it has been trying to do that for a long time.

There are lots of new ideas being bandied around at the moment, my favourite being a Dutch Grand Prix. Given the popularity of Max Verstappen, this should not be difficult, particularly if it was to be a street race.

There is still much talk of cost-cutting, but increasingly it seems that reducing the spend and balancing revenues for all the teams may require some creative solutions rather han simply declaring that only x amount of money can be spent. One way that this can be done is for there to be changes to the structure of the F1 driver market, for example. At the moment this is all left unstructured. The big teams hire the big drivers and pay what they need to pay them. But what if they couldn’t do that? What if the rules gave the first choice of drivers each year to the least successful teams? Thus Sauber would get the first choice of drivers and could pick Lewis Hamilton. He would not want to stay, but Sauber could then put him on the market and would then reap the benefits of the money required to release him. This would raise money for the little teams and things would get interesting in the midfield. This could be fairly similar to the National Football League “Draft” in the United States, an event at the best college players are signed up by the teams in the professional leagues. Today The Draft is a three-day televised event in which the players are selected and traded. This year it attracted an astonishing 250,000 spectators at the venue, with millions more watching on TV, with the show producing solid advertising revenues – and the whole event acting as free promotion for the sport. The big teams would still be allowed to spend money but it would serve a purpose!

83 thoughts on “Notebook from DXB

  1. I don’t like the idea of treating people be they drivers or not as assets to be sold. This sort of thing could be seen as a “restraint of trade”, football got into all sort troubles with the eu over teams owning players in the past.

      1. Established players are not “drafted” by the worst teams in the NFL. though.
        They become free agents, able to sign with any team willing to pay them the most. They can take less money to sign with a better team if they like.
        F1 teams can sign any youngster the like and sell their deal to another as it is, can’t they? So, F1 already has that process in place. It just can’t be monetized like the NFL draft is.

      2. True. With very multinational sports like F1 it must make lots of work for lawyers working out which laws on things like employment, tax, advertising etc apply to which of the people involved in F1.

      3. The NFL has an exemption from U.S. anti-trust laws, which is why they are able to get away with it.
        Such a scheme would transfer wealth from the top-third of drivers to the bottom-third of teams. The large teams are not going to bear all of the additional cost of buying drivers out of their commitment to poorer teams.

      4. Joe, what (country) jurisdiction FOM/F1 are operating under? Can they switch to some more liberate rather than say EU or whatever they are under at present so to make things more easy and less bureaucratic ?

      1. Because they have an exemption from U.S. anti-trust laws, just like NFL and MLB. Not applicable to FOM; it’s a for-profit entity, its activities are primarily ex-US, and it has zero “presence” in the minds of US Congress and voters.

  2. One problem I can see for visitors to Hanoi (or Vietnam in general…) is they may never get to the circuit if it involves crossing a road by foot. It takes a certain amount of nerve to weave through all the scooters (many with 2-3-4 passengers, at least two on a phone) with no regard to which side of the road they /should/ be on, and if you’re used to standard pedestrian crossings, forget it!

    1. I was in Ho Chi Minh City last year. For the first day it was daunting, but by the second day we found if you just start crossing, the scooters will make their way around you!

  3. An alternative could be the concept of “claiming” cars as used in other forms of motorsport to reduce costs. For a fee of $x million a smaller team can claim a competitor car at the end of the season to use itself next year. Of course there are technical difficulties but I wonder for example how much money say Ferrari would pour into development if they knew Sauber could simply claim their car after Abu Dhabi and repaint it for 2018 ?

    1. No need for anyone to claim a car at seasons end. The simple fix is this. Make ALL F1 designs open source at the end of the year. Engines, chassis, aero the works. Arms race stops as cars converge rapidly. Those that cant afford can catch up.. Then Lewis may want to stay at Sauber if they were not a mile away from Mercedes. But costs will tumble as Mr. Newey and others skills are openly available to all. But by making it available 1st jan and NOT seasons end, with new cars begin designed about June a clever idea has a 18 month shelf life. Long enough in F1 terms. SHort enough to allow the minnows to get on parity with the big teams. Don’t forget the big teams can afford to buy talented engineers that these ideas are already open source to them. This just levels the playing field.

  4. I just don’t like the draft idea at all it’s possible some of wrong drivers will end in the wrong cars. In fact you’ll probably end up with the same driver moves with a draft system as without it.

  5. Draft is a fake way for backmarkers to get few extra millions if they are lucky – it doesn’t address any of their problems (money would still be small) nor solve any of them. Sounds like some of ideas of mr. E

  6. I’m still not sold of Kvyat in 2018. Is that really the best that is available?

    Brendon Hartley I think is someone that should be considered for that Toro Rosso seat. He is a Porsche works driver without a drive for next year. If Porsche is to enter the sport with the new engine regs it will be through a Red Bull team.

    1. Is that a Wasabi, Sweet Potato or Green Tea Kyvat? Probably should be Vodka, unless he’s under 25 of course.

  7. Joe how would a draft type of situation work with new drivers graduating from GP2 or another series? Likewise how would drivers drop out other than retirement?
    I think potentially its a great idea. How does the rest of F1 see Senna these days?

  8. F1 isn’t NFL. Not by a long way. American football is played at school, college and professionally. There are no other teams. Once a player stops, that’s it, there’s no playing for another country, your village or pub. It ain’t football as we know it. The NFL teams don’t have academies like RB, Ferrari & McLaren, they don’t need them. Why would RB bother with running their own training scheme, if Force India snaffled their top graduate? Drivers have managers, they’re not all dodgy geezers, would they be out of a job?

    Then we have the big one, the money. If Sauber held the contract for Lewis Hamilton and demanded £10m for it, great for them, but that’s money Lewis wouldn’t receive, because Mercedes wouldn’t want to pay twice for his services.
    The teams would just increase contract lengths and do deals amongst themselves.

    Neither FOM or the FIA should have any control over any contracts in F1, be it drivers, engineers or truck drivers. FOM need to file this in the bin, along with their idea of individually introducing all the drivers to the spectators on some fancy stage at the next race. If a sport can’t hold it’s own without the need for dancing ladies, pop concerts and bling laden celebs, then it’s dying on its feet.

  9. …”I’ve always wanted to write an article to show where F1 people are, 12 hours after a race”…
    Dear Joe,
    why not just place videos&photos in instagram before, during and after Grand Prix?
    I guess all the fans would appreciate this 😉

    1. I’ve seen the worn-out mechanics at the airports on Mondays, not the best of pictures, I guess. They weren’t very talkative either, which is understandable.

  10. Is Alexander Rossi available for the Austin race?

    btw – After attending the Suzuka race, I took the same Kintetsu train as you from Shiroko to Osaka Namba on Sunday evening and then onto Kansai Airport on Monday late afternoon 🙂

  11. I guess it’s impossible to realise, but from a spectator’s perspective, the best would be to see the drivers rotate through all the cars throughout the season.

  12. If there was some kind of draft system for drivers then we might get slow teams getting even slower in attempts to get the first pick for next season. Things could get pretty silly.

  13. The NBA is another US sport that is doing extremely well.

    They have a draft system and a soft cap, i.e. a limit of how much money they can spend on player salaries. Soft because it has many different exceptions, and if want to spend more, you can, but you have to pay a “luxury tax”.

    This “system” is negotiated between a players union and the owners for several years, the revenues are shared almost 50/50 between players and owners. Players can be moved against their will, but given what they are paid, it is seldom an issue.

    What the NBA has done over the years is increase the international audience. They changed the rules so that the game is more attractive closer to European basketball.

    Almost all teams now have international players, apart from local and national TV deals in the US you can watch them play worldwilde via the NBAs own streaming service.

    Some of the arenas are build with public money, and the teams sign long term deals to use it. In the end, I think these terms are most advantageous to the teams, but then they prestige to the city in question, a bit like an F1 race raises the profile of a city or country.

    Interestingly, the NBA still has “small market” and “big market” teams, the latter are able to create more money via local TV deals and because of their heritage, so despite all efforts, there will always be teams that can and will spend more, even though they initally “earn” the some through league, e.g. the LA Lakers.

    However, there are differences to the NBA, which make negotiatons more complicated.

    The NBA is owned by the teams themselves, not a third party like the FOM.

    They can make their own playing rules, this does not happend via an international body like the FIA.

    In F1 some teams also develop and supply engines to other teams, thereby having a direct influence on their performance.

    In the NBA, players are the main differentiator of perfomance between teams.

    In F1, most of the performance (therefore money spend) is created “in the background” by engineers and development teams.

    Sure, good drivers are important, but we have all seen Alonso in a bad car, he might drive the wheels of it, but he cannot make them a winning team. On the other hand, sometimes an average to good driver in a very good car can achieve great results.

    So auditing a cost cap will be more difficult, because one has to look at many things and not just one variable.

    Let’s see how these will be negotiated, but if look you at the price an NBA is sold these days, 2.2 billion $, than this should be an incentive to make it work.

  14. “Blow your head clean off”. Where did I hear that before?

    I’ve kinda lost track what with all this excitement…

  15. It’s a shame the political situation with China would never allow it, but Taiwan would make a great F1 destination, and an even better WRC one. The people there love their cars as well as being massively friendly and helpful.

    I don’t know if it’s the same people run 7Eleven in Japan as Taiwan but if so there is much more to choose from than limp egg sandwiches but for a real treat in Japan, check out Mos Burger. It makes McDonalds look frankly pathetic. Both are chains I wish would come to the UK… (Provided we didn’t westernise them and ruin the quality and selection that is…)

  16. Having travelled to Hanoi for business and leisure I have to agree that “The Grand Old Dame of the Orient” is a fantastic place to visit. There is a lot to see and do and the colonial architecture in the old part of the city is immense.

    I found the Vietnamese government owned businesses I worked with to be incredibly bureaucratic (as you would expect) but if the support for the race goes all the way to the top I’m sure things will be made a bit easier for the F1 circus.

    1. Was a few years ago but Hanoi was beautiful city, old buildings and charm and totally different from the rest of the major cities in SE Asia which are identical high rises. Hope its not a street race in Hanoi. Be shame to loose such a beautiful city. Us old backpackers are finding it harder to get away from the tourists and global chains and selfie picture takers.
      Hope that Paul gets a seat. F1 not the same without a Scot taking part.

      Thanks Joe for the notes and the trip review, very nice. Hope you get over jet lag before next flight

  17. Someone once mentioned an idea that at the end of each season the Intellectual Property associated to parts used on that seasons car, should be made available to close up the field. Don’t know if that would work with engines as well as chassis, but it would certainly close the field up significantly, but still allow the top teams to try and find a Brawn double diffuser style loophole, occasionally

  18. Joe re the Draft – Would this work for engineers coming our of Universities as well?
    Surely then those teams at the back could have first pick of the best up and coming engineers?

  19. If my info is correct, Kubica is testing right now in Silverstone in a Williams, but that could be hopeful wishing.
    Any news on who will drive the second Toro Rosso in Austin (since Gasly will drive in Japan that weekend)? What are your thoughts?

      1. I do live elsewhere.

        Yet I still consider it a simple courtesy to use the name and spelling a sovereign state gives to locations within its jurisdiction.

        YMMV.

        1. I am writing this blog for people all over the world. So clearly I use the accepted names, not the local ones. Otherwise I’d have to write about Deutschland, Magyarország, Milano, Ciudad de México, 上海市, البحرين and Nihon. So logically I write the names people know.

          1. You’re a writer. Educating your readership is part of your remit.

            The fact that a number of your readers may have no interest in Googling 上海市 and learning what it means is a straw man. They may display a similar level of interest in learning what ‘DXB’ means too. This didn’t prevent you from using it.

            It’s no biggie. I simply felt it would have been in the spirit of your ‘Notebook’ to do things like this.

            Clearly I was wrong.

          2. No pleasing some people is there Joe..
            Great notebook 📓 thank you ..I am not convinced about another street race, just my opinion of course ..

        2. That’s not true.
          Rome is spelled Rom, Roma, Rzym and so on in different languages. As well as Paris can be spelled Paryż, Parigi. So Hanoi is not wrong.

      2. Ha Noi is the Vietnamese for Hanoi. But as we are all speaking English here… Hanoi is good. It would be like getting offended if Joe were to go to Shanghai and not call it 上海.

  20. Loved the intro to this blog, it’s fascinating to get a real feel for the lifestyle of an F1 journo and your blog does just that in recreating the ambience of the surroundings and the cuisine, etc, thanks Joe.

  21. Joe – The draft idea is very creative – might be tough to implement but the concept of mechanisms for creating balance is sound. Several have been presented here by you and others and with the new regime in place, why not throw them all out to be considered? Draft for F2 drivers, Claiming cars at the end of the year, Relegation, Weight penalties? What else can we think of? I suspect the Liberty guys read your blog and seem like a rather open lot.

  22. There are plenty of young vloggers who would happily follow you around for a few days to document the movements. Also would access a whole new (younger) market.

    1. That would involve two things which are impossible: the cost to fund this; and the right to film at circuits.

      1. An occasional video blog would be enjoyable, outside the track of course, about your travels good or bad. It’s very popular I believe among the yoot, vlogging, that is. Maybe even an end of year vlog with DT when you’ve left Yas Marina and have a bit of time to summarise the season. Stick it on a private youtube channel for GP+ subscribers, maybe? Anyway, thanks for the notebook.

  23. Thanks for the blog. Has there ever been a discussion of a “luxury tax” rather than a budget cap? They had or have this in Major League Baseball where a team that spent over an established amount would get “charged” a tax, say 25%, on the amount over the limit. So, if the limit is $150 million and a team spends $170 the have to pay an extra $5million to a fund. One could imagine that fund could go to the lower spending teams while still allowing the big spenders to keep spending.

  24. Thank you once again for opening the green notebook for us Joe.

    Incidentally I saw said green notebook in your hand on NBCSN race coverage in the US as you were talking with Damon Hill on the grid and Will Buxton came up for a quick word. You sure got the hell out of the camera view quick! Will was cutely giddy on air after his brief conversation with Damon saying “He’s my hero, as a youngster I used to get up at all hours of the morning to watch him here, I cant believe I get to talk to him.” A nice reminder that many of the folks in F1 are in fact fans first, which led them to work in the sport.

  25. Is the average Vietnamese prosperous enough to buy F1 tickets? It is a growing economy and a surprisingly large population of 94 million. But if F1 goes there, I want it done right. Not a five-years-and-time-to-move-on.

  26. Moto GP has standard software that is used by 7 manufacturers they didn’t like it at first but it’s accepted now & the racing is closer also lower teams should have more engines per season & more testing till they reach a certain result.

  27. Hi Joe, excellent notebook entry as always!

    The world surfing tour has a similar media set up as F1 in that there is an official outlet and other non-official publications/individuals reporting. Recently it has been decided that the non-official media will boycott a finals day for reasons that are not worth going into here.

    would the non-official F1 media, such as yourself, consider minimising their coverage of Ferrari as a reaction to their lack of engagement? it seems petty, but maybe then they would realise your worth.

    thanks,
    cb

  28. Sounds quite funny that some of you start at the track, head off in opposite directions then meet up again at the same airport! I think Mr Ron Dennis could optimise the process for you but it might cost $4 billion.

  29. Hanoi would be a terrific F1 venue. Not a purpose built Tilke track that’s 2 hours out of town, but something around Hoan Kiem Lake Park for example, would be spectacular.

    1. May be, but on average city tracks are high on spectacle and low on race excitement. F1 car need space to show them selfs at their awe inspiring best.

  30. The added benefit of having a race in the north of Vietnam is the proximity to China. This is particularly important given the crackdown in travel to other destinations by the Chinese government.

  31. With a driver draft i think it may be a good idea for rookie drivers, may be for their first 3 years. With only a few seats per year this will make the “draft” headcount somewhere close to interesting. However it’s never going to pull viewership like the NFL.

    On another tangent, how about allowing more test days with a portion of these test days being tradable on an anonymous auction/exchange administered by the FIA (to counter junior teams giving all their test days to the senior team) ?

    The wealth transfer effect will happen and lagging teams can choose to keep the days to get themselves up the rungs.

    Together these 2 ideas will really help the mid and tail end of the field i think.

  32. Will Lewis take the knee, all hell will break loose , if he does I can see the team ditching it , one thing I love about F1, no politics in the country off the race. What do you think he will do Joe. Also who is your bet For the seat at Toro Rosso.

  33. Hi Joe, personally I love the green tea Kit Kats and always ask my wife to bring a box back from her business trips to Japan.

    On the subject of non Japanese drivers being popular, is it true that Jenson Button was very well supported there? Not as much as Senna of course but I always got the impression that because he had a Japanese girlfriend who then became his wife (and thus many Japanese friends/family) he was accepted as an honorary Japanese driver. He certainly appeared to be genuinely moved by the awful events that followed the Terrible earthquake and tsunami a few years back and if memory serves had a special message on his car as a mark of respect. The fact that Jenson-san drove for Honda for some years probably didn’t hurt.

    Great GP+ this week, many thanks to all! P

  34. The Japanese have a longer and closer history of involvement with international and Western culture than some of the other Asian F1 counties. Also, besides Singapore which has done well too, they’re more affluent as well. Add that to the length of time Japan has been involved with F1 and automotive manufacturing and it’s not great mystery why F1 does well there.

  35. As for Vietnam, I know many well-heeled friends who are taking luxury vacations there. It’s an open secret that many people feel Vietnam is a place to go for luxury, tranquil vacations away from the backpacker, sex tourists and budget tourists who descend on highly developed Thailand.

Leave a comment